Question:
My dad tells me that putting an acoustic guitar by a radio (radio on)
will vibrate the wood and give the guitar a better
tone. Will the radio give the guitar a better tone?
Eddie W.
Answer:
A solid wood acoustic guitar sounds better over the years as you play
it and the
wood breaks in. The wood fibers actually loosen up and the
wood vibrates
easier, so the theory is: Why not vibrate the wood even while not
playing it by
using an external sound to speed up the process? I know from
experience that external sounds can
vibrate a guitar. While waiting my turn to go on, I'll be
sitting there holding my
guitar and the orchestra will be playing and sometimes my guitar will
REALLY
vibrate from the sounds of the orchestra. It surprised me big
time the
first time it happened.
I've read about lab tests in which someone has tried to vibrate new
guitars and
measure the difference in sound. The measurements were
probably not too
scientific since the differences were measured with human ears but on
some
certain models of guitars, they noticed quite a difference.
Other models
not so much.
I guess if you have a safe place to leave your guitar out, others you
live with
don't mind the constant radio turned up loud enough to vibrate the
wood, and putting a lot of user time on your
stereo isn't a problem, leaving your stereo on would be a thing to
consider.
I know a music store that keeps their new solid wood guitars in a glass
display case with music playing to break in the wood.
Bob, Gman ( o )==#
G-man:
The radio method WILL help to break in a good guitar---but there's a
better way, and most of us can figure out a way to do it. Works not
only on guitars, but all wooden instruments, including bassoons,
violins, clarinets, etc.
A radio will ordinarily render a frequency range across a very limited
spectrum. Even if your guitar "listens" to the "Steely Dan" station
non-stop, nonetheless, the full spectrum of frequencies isn't accessed.
We want to vibrate our instruments across their full range PLUS as high
up into the harmonics as our speakers will go, up in the 20K range, if
possible, and even beyond, if we have engineering facilities and the
tweeters to pull it off.
The best way to "vibrate in" a guitar is to create a sine wave---as
bright as possible---and run it from low E up as high as possible, then
back down, then up, etc. The issue isn't just rattling the wood; you
could do that any number of other ways. The issue is that wood fibers
connect together in many patterns, and to "shake them loose" (actually,
we don't shake them loose so much as we straighten them out somewhat),
it takes different pitches for different wood-fiber-connections.
The sine wave ought to take about one minute from bottom to top and one
minute from top to bottom. You don't want to go fast, because in the
lower register, the strings will pick up vibrations and ring out
overtones and do some of the "rattling" work for the instrument all on
its own.
The way I do this is as follows: I created a sine wave with some
computer software I have, recorded it to a CD, then stuck a single
speaker and the guitar in a closet full of clothes. Can't even hear it.
I suspend the guitar by the neck so that the body can shake for all its
worth. I loop the CD recording and it runs all day while I'm at work.
You DON'T have to make it particularly loud! The objective is to
vibrate the body, not shake the glue joints loose.
It drives the parrot crazy.
I picked this tid-bit up from some violin makers, plus just sort of
thinking about it.
FWIW.
Nice website you've got.
Hal McSwain